| Year | Name | Sport | School |
| 2002 | Kyle Eash | Football, Track and Field | Illinois Wesleyan University |
| Claudia Veritas | Lacrosse | Wellesley College | |
| 2001 | Bradley Henderson | Basketball | University of Chicago |
| Kimberly Black | Swimming | University of Georgia | |
| 2000 | Matthew Busbee | Swimming | Auburn University |
| Anna Hallbergson | Tennis | Barry University | |
| 1999 | Samuel "Calvin" Thigpen | Track, Cross Country | University of Mississippi |
| Gladys Ganiel | Track, Cross Country | Providence College | |
| 1998 | Robert "Brad" Gray | Football | Massachusetts Institute of Technology |
| Marsha Harris | Basketball | New York University | |
| 1997 | Scott Keane | Track & Field | University of Cincinnati |
| Marya Morusiewicz | Volleyball | Barry University | |
| 1996 | Christopher Palmer | Football | Saint John's University |
| Tracey Holmes | Golf | University of Kentucky | |
| 1995 | Robert Zatechka | Football | University of Nebraska-Lincoln |
| Carla Ainsworth | Swimming | Kenyon College | |
| 1994 | Randal Pinkett | Track & Field | Rutgers University |
| Christa Gannon | Basketball | University of California at Santa Barbara | |
| 1993 | Rob Pelinka | Basketball | University of Michigan |
| Sheryl Klemme | Basketball | Saint Joseph College | |
| 1992 | David Honea | Cross Country | North Carolina State University |
| Sigall Kassutto | Gymnastics | University of California at Berkeley | |
| 1991 | J. David Brown | Track, Cross Country | University of Iowa |
| Marie Roethlisberger | Gymnastics | University of Minnesota | |
| 1990 | Dean Smith | Basketball | University of Maine |
| Linda Popovich | Volleyball | Bowling Green State University | |
| 1989 | Richard Hall | Basketball | Ball State University |
| Regina Cavanagh | Track & Field | Rice University |
© The National Collegiate Athletic Association