| NCAA Provisional/Exploratory Members | |||
| March 1, 2007 | |||
| Division I | Division II | Division III | |
| Active 2007-08 |
1. Keystone College | ||
| Year 4 | 2. University of Texas at Tyler | ||
| 3. Tri-State University | |||
| Active 2008-09 |
1. Utah Valley State College | 1. California State University, Monterey Bay | 1. Crown College, MN |
| Year 3 | 2. Central State University | 2. University of Maine at Presque Isle | |
| 3. North Georgia College & State University | 3. Mount Aloysius College | ||
| 4. Palm Beach Atlantic University | 4. Mount Mary College | ||
| 5. Penn State Berks College | |||
| Active 2009-10 |
1. University of Mary | 1. Bethany Lutheran College | |
| Year 2 | 2. Claflin University | 2. LaSierra University | |
| 3. Mitchell College | |||
| 4. North Central University | |||
| 5. Northwestern College | |||
| 6. Presentation College | |||
| 7. Purchase College | |||
| 8 . Salem College | |||
| Active 2010-11 |
1. Brevard College | 1. Lancaster Bible College | |
| Year 1 | 2. Dixie State College of Utah | 2. Lyndon State College | |
| 3. Flagler College | 3. Saint Vincent College | ||
| 4. Georgia Southwestern and State University | 4. SUNY at Morrisville | ||
| 5. Newman University | |||
| 6. Notre Dame de Namur University | |||
| 7. Seton Hill University | |||
| 8. Texas A&M International University | |||
| 9. University of Texas at the Permian Basin | |||
| Exploratory | Provisional 07-08 | 1. Auburn University, Montgomery | 1. Franciscan University of Steubenville |
| DII Active - 08-09 | 2. Briarcliffe College | 2. Geneva College | |
| 3. King College | 3. Penn State Harrisburg | ||
| 4. Northwood College (FL) | 4. Spalding University | ||
| 5. St. Joseph's College (NY) | |||
| Provisional 08-09 | 1. University of Cincinnati Clermont College | ||
| 2. Doane College | |||
| 3. SUNY at Cobleskill | |||