SUMMARY OF ACTIONS/RECOMMENDATIONS

 

NCAA DIVISION III MANAGEMENT COUNCIL MEETING

January 6, 2006

 

NCAA DIVISION III PRESIDENTS COUNCIL MEETING

January 7. 2006

 

 

TABLE OF CONTENTS

 

 

Association-wide committees…

 

Committee on Competitive Safeguards and Medical Aspects of Sports (CSMAS)

Page 1

Honors Committee

Page 1

Minority Opportunities and Interest Committee (MOIC)

Page 2

Committee on Sportsmanship and Ethical Conduct

Page 4

Committee on Women’s Athletics (CWA)

Page 7

Joint Meeting of the Committee on Women’s Athletics (CWA) and Minority Opportunities and Interests Committee (MOIC)

Page 8

 

 

 

 

Division III committees/subcommittees…

 

Strategic Initiatives Grant Program

Page 9

MC/PC Future of Division III – Phase II

Page 10

MC Academics Issues Subcommittee

Page 12

MC Administrative Review Subcommittee

Page 13

Budget Committee

Page 13

Financial Aid Committee

Page 14

Committee on Infractions

Page 16

Interpretations and Legislation Committee

Page 16

Membership Committee

Page 17

Student-Athlete Advisory Committee (SAAC)

Page 18

Convention-Planning Subcommittee

Page 21

2006 NCAA Convention

Page 22

 

 

 

 

Legislation…

 

Governance Structure

Page 23

Noncontroversial

Page 23

Administrative Regulations

Page 25

 

 

 

 

General Issues…

 

Management/Presidents Council Committee/Subcommittee Assignments

Page 25

Presidents Council Attendance Policy

Page 25

 

 

 


REPORT OF THE

 

NCAA DIVISION III MANAGEMENT COUNCIL MEETING

January 6, 2006

 

NCAA DIVISION III PRESIDENTS COUNCIL MEETING

January 7, 2006

 

NCAA DIVISION III POST-CONVENTION MANAGEMENT COUNCIL MEETING

January 10, 2006 (Attachment A)

 

2006 CONVENTION VOTING RESULTS (Attachment B)

 

AW – COMMITTEE ON COMPETITITVE SAFEGUARDS AND MEDICAL ASPECTS OF SPORTS

Staff Liaisons:  Klossner; Wilfert

Council Rep:  Wilson

ISSUE:  Division III Year-Round Drug Testing Two-Year Pilot.

Council Recommendation:

1.             Support in principle $400,000 in the 2006-08 biennial budget to potentially establish a voluntary Year-Round Drug Testing Two-Year Pilot program in Division III.

2.             Request the committee to develop a formal proposal for review at the Council’s April 2006 meeting noting:

·         Inclusion of Division III specific data to assist with evaluation of issue.

·         Number of Division III campuses that currently engage in some type of drug testing, if available.

·         Turn around time for pilot data/results.

·         Plan for institutional solicitation, communication and broad-based representation.

The Council also noted:

·              Initiative supports student-athlete well-being.

·              Division responsibility to consider, given well established year-round testing in Divisions I and II.

·              May be viewed as invasive, particularly for testing beyond performance enhancement.

·              Education remains an important component of student-athlete well-being.

Presidents Council Action:

Approved the recommendation.

 

MC SUPPLEMENT NO. 1

AW – HONORS COMMITTEE

Staff Liaisons:  Lawrence

Council Rep:  Gleason

ISSUE:  2006 Silver Anniversary Award Selections.

Management Council Action:

Accepted the information that the committee selected the following honorees for the Silver Anniversary Award:  Valerie Ackerman (University of Virginia), Danny Ainge (Brigham Young University), Charles Davis (Vanderbilt University), Terry Schroeder (Pepperdine University), Mike Singletary (Baylor University) and Susan D. Wellington (Yale University).

 

ISSUE:  Top VIII Award Selections.


Management Council Action:

Accepted the information that the committee selected eight NCAA Top VIII Award Recipients:

·                Division I.  Samantha Arsenault (University of Georgia); Nicholas Hartigan (Brown University); DeMeco Ryans (University of Alabama, Tuscaloosa); Richard Simpson (University of Nebraska, Lincoln); Christine Sinclair (University of Portland); and Jamie Southern (California State University, Fresno).

·               Division II.  Sarah Dance (Truman State University).

·                Division III.  Carter Hamill (Amherst College).

 

ISSUE:  Theodore Roosevelt Award Selection.

Management Council Action: 

Accepted the information that the committee selected Robert K. Kraft as the 2006 Theodore Roosevelt Award recipient.

 

ISSUE:  2006 Inspiration Award Recipients.

Management Council Action:

Accepted the information that the committee selected Raul Altreche (Amherst College), John Doar (Princeton University) and Lois Taurman (Bellarmine University) as the 2006 Inspiration recipients.

 

ISSUE:  2006 Honors Reception.

Management Council Action:

Accepted the information that the 2006 Honors Reception will be held Saturday, January 7 at the Murat Theatre in Indianapolis.  Jack Ford was selected as master of ceremonies.

 

ISSUE:  Committee Chair.

Management Council Action:

Accepted the information that Timothy W. Gleason (Ohio Athletic Conference) was selected as the new committee chair.

 

MC SUPPLEMENT NO. 2

AW – NCAA MINORITY OPPORTUNITIES AND INTERESTS COMMITTEE (MOIC)

Staff Liaisons:  Westerhaus, Jackson, Shipps

Council Rep:  Wong

ISSUE:  The 2004 Racial and Gender Report Card.

Management Council Action:

Accepted the information that the committee discussed the 2004 Racial and Gender Report Card that was published June 2, 2005.  The report card uses official NCAA data; however the conclusions and grades were determined by The Institute for Diversity and Ethics in Sport.  The committee specifically noted that Division I-A conference offices, head coaches, athletics directors, presidents and faculty athletics representatives received either an “F” or “D+” with regard to gender and racial diversity.  The committee determined that in order to effectuate change in these areas, presidents and chancellors must be educated about the lack of diversity in intercollegiate athletics administration and how diversity will benefit their athletics department.

The committee noted that although the national office received a “B+” and “A+” with regard to race and gender, there seems to be constant turnover at the staff level.  The committee asked the staff to determine where people of color and women go after leaving the NCAA national office and whether those individuals leave for better opportunities or decide to leave intercollegiate athletics. 

ISSUE:  NCAA Coaching Academies.

Management Council Action:

Accepted the information that the committee received an update regarding the NCAA Men’s Coaches Academy and the NCAA Women Coaches Academy.  The committee discussed the perception of the programs and the participants’ preparedness for upper athletics coaching positions upon completion of the academies.  The committee also asked the staff to take a detailed review of the academies to determine if the academies should include coaches from all sports.

 

ISSUE:  MOIC Strategic Plan.

Management Council Action:

Accepted the information that the committee reviewed each objective of the 2003-05 MOIC Strategic Plan noting its relevance and whether it was met in the prescribed time period.  The committee recommended several changes for the 2006-08 MOIC Strategic Plan noting that the plan will be finalized at the next committee meeting in January 2006.

 

ISSUE:  Budget.

Management Council Action:

Accepted the information that the committee discussed budget priorities for the 2006-07 and 2007-08 fiscal years.  Specifically, the committee reviewed current allocated programs for the 2005-06 fiscal year, reallocations and new budget requests for the 2006-07 and 2007-08 fiscal years.  The committee met jointly with the Committee on Women’s Athletics to discuss budget items that are sponsored by both committees.  The committee chairs will meet with staff at a later date to finalize all budget requests.

 

ISSUE:  Native American Mascot Issue.

Management Council Action:

Accepted the information that the staff provided the committee an overview of the issues surrounding American Indian mascots, imagery or nicknames in intercollegiate athletics including the actions of the Executive Committee Subcommittee on Gender and Diversity Issues and Executive Committee actions regarding this issue.  In addition, the staff reviewed the appeals process and provided the committee with an update of all appeals decided at the staff level.

 

ISSUE:  Office for Diversity and Inclusion.

Management Council Action:

Accepted the information that Charlotte Westerhaus provided a brief update on external and internal office for diversity and inclusion initiatives including staffing the office of diversity and inclusion. 

 

ISSUE:  Senior Woman Administrator Update.

Management Council Action:

Accepted the information that staff provided the committee with an update from the Executive Committee regarding the role of the senior woman administrator (SWA).  Specifically, the staff informed the committee that the Executive Committee requested that the appropriate governance entities sponsor legislation as a common provision in all three divisions, amending the definition of an SWA as follows:  “An institutional senior woman administrator is the highest ranking female involved with the management of a member institution’s intercollegiate athletics program.  An institution with a female director of athletics may designate a different female administrator involved with the management of the member’s program as a fifth representative to the NCAA governance system.” 

The Council requested a formal membership communication regarding this issue.

 

ISSUE:  Hurricane Katrina.

Management Council Action:

Accepted the information that the committee discussed the NCAA response regarding relief efforts in Louisiana, Mississippi and Alabama noting that there was not much public information on the NCAA’s response to the hurricane relief efforts.  In addition, the committee noted that some Historically Black Colleges and Universities in the region suffered extreme structural and financial damage as a result of Hurricane Katrina and that some of these institutions will not be able to recover as quickly as other institutions in the area. 

 

MC SUPPLEMENT NO. 3

AW – COMMITTEE ON SPORTSMANSHIP AND ETHICAL CONDUCT.

Staff Liaisons:  Newman, Roe, Stratten

Council Rep:  Slabik

ISSUE:  Committee Discussion on Philosophy and Charge of the Committee.

Management Council Action:

Accepted the information that the committee discussed the purpose of the committee, questioning what issues the committee should be engaged in and what relevance the committee should have in the membership in terms of being a resource, being a watchdog and being an advocate related to sportsmanship.  The members agreed that the committee should have a two-pronged approach to its work.  The first prong should address the strategic plan, including a focus on best practices to achieve and foster an environment of sportsmanship.  The second prong would relate to holding institutions, administrators, coaches and student-athletes accountable for the actions that undermine good sportsmanship.  Also, it would recognize actions that promote and exemplify good sportsmanship.

The committee agreed to form two subcommittee representing all three divisions to carry forth the charge of the committee:

  • Accountability subcommittee.
  • Strategic planning subcommittee.

Each subcommittee will convene prior to the committee’s next meeting to specify its charge and action plan.  Ron Loghry, Big Sky Conference, will chair the accountability subcommittee, and Alan Patterson, Carolinas-Virginia Athletic Conference, will chair the Strategic Planning Subcommittee.

 

ISSUE:  Mission Statement Discussion.

Management Council Action:

Accepted the information that the committee reviewed and reaffirmed the mission statement.

 

ISSUE:  Division III Commissioners Association Sportsmanship and Ethical Conduct.

Management Council Action:

Accepted the information that Chuck Mitrano (Empire 8) reported on the work of the Division III commissioners group, which is examining initiatives to explore and implement.  The group has identified two focus areas:  (1) compiling and sharing best practices for addressing sportsmanship issues ranging from game management and fan conduct to educational programs; and (2) conducting a comparison between institutions and conferences that track conduct fouls in real time with those institutions and conferences that do not track and report the information contemporaneously.  The committee also received a copy of the Division III Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference soccer program as a resource to use in addressing concerns in the sport of soccer.

 

ISSUE:  Sports Wagering Update.

Management Council Action:

Accepted the information:

(1)          Sports Wagering Task Force Initiative Update.

·               Staff noted that the sports wagering Web site dedicated to student-athletes is nearing the end of the design phase and the staff will be seeking reaction and feedback from the
Student-Athlete Advisory committees (SAACs) at the January 2006 meetings.  The goal is to launch the Web site prior to the 2006 men’s and women’s basketball tournaments.

·